Mansi, one of the readers here, asked the following question:
“We all know that in almost 100% of the cases:- mother in law and daughter in law clash – why is this? Please do a post on this.”
Mansi’s question appears as a comment in this post:
I will answer the question the way I see it. I would welcome others’ thoughts, experiences, and perspectives.
In a patriarchal system, women take up positions of inferiority. The girl child, teenager, and the young woman is taught or coerced into the following during the formative years(the opposite traits I’ve listed in parentheses):
- unquestioning obedience (versus reasoning, questioning, analysis)
- acceptance of fate or destiny (versus proactive problem solving)
- a sense of weakness, vulnerability (versus strength, confidence)
- inferiority (versus a sense of equality)
- shame in one’s body (versus seeing it in neutral, biological terms)
- shame in the pursuit of pleasure (versus seeing it as a natural human trait)
- no personal interests or hobbies or achievements (versus encouraging personal accomplishment)
- assigned pre-ordained roles (versus having choices)
- constraints on the smallest things (versus having daily freedoms like going for a walk safely, taking the city bus safely, going to college safely, going to work safely)
- constraints on life decisions (choosing whom to marry, choosing whether to marry or not, choosing not to stay in an unhappy marriage)
- permission seeking fit for children (as opposed to adult freedoms – permission to visit parents after marriage, permission to work, to not have kids yet, or to not have kids period)
Some of the above have changed with times, primarily:
- education and careers – girls and women now pursue these – but even here the context remains vastly patriarchal – do they have control over their paycheck – do they know how to spend, save and invest their money – do they have the freedom to work where and when they want in a field they choose, the freedom to travel for a job – do they have the supports needed at home to succeed at work or do they carry the triple burden of work, home, and kids
- some of the other factors mentioned above have changed for some families (who raise girls as humans that are allowed human joys and weaknesses, and granted equal rights) but remain true for the vast majority to different degrees.
So, what happens to girls and young women raised with these traits? They develop low self esteem. They have been constantly told of their lack of worth and they begin to believe it. Not just about themselves but about all women. Their gender is the dreaded gender, they are the unlucky ones.
The all-pervading misogyny is internalized by women. Different women react to this in different ways. They develop coping mechanisms such as –
- judging other women (partly because they genuinely believe women should be judged, society has given everyone the right to judge this group of human beings, but partly because they see themselves in other women. “She is a lazy stay at home mom who watches TV all day.” because they’ve heard this comment over and over again and unthinkingly repeat it. Or, “she is too selfish and not a good mother, look at her, travelling so much” because this is another stereotypical comment that they’ve heard over and over again
- petty competition – women in a patriarchy must compete for male attention to win a few crumbs of freedom – putting other women down has a concrete advantage
- becoming a martyr – in a patriarchy, you can either be a Goddess on a pedestal or evil incarnate – ordinary human traits like ambition and pleasure in women become evil – self-sacrifice is considered virtuous. Some women engage in self-denial and sacrifice to feel rewarded by the families and societies they live in.
- passing the baton – the teaching of these “feminine” rules and traits strangely falls upon women – victims create more victims in the process – women are taught early on “to be a good example to their daughters”. Every time a woman doesn’t toe the line, her parents and her upbringing are blamed. There is an entire cannon of virtue that needs to be passed down the generations – and some women assume this role whole heartedly.
All of the above come into play in the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law situation.
The mother-in-law belongs to a generation of women that have been denied an education, the right to work, the right to choices. They have been raised with low self-esteem and their most ardent sacrifices have been barely acknowledged. They have never enjoyed the companionship and respect of their life partners. Rather they served their lords and received nothing of worth in return.
The typical difficult mother-in-law is not an evil woman – she is an ordinary woman reacting to the above factors related to her upbringing. She is coping in her own way, trying to find in her own distorted, sad way – some kind of path to perceived happiness. All her life she’s been controlled by other men. So she sees control as the singular thing absent from her life. She tries to exercise control over the one person who is in the lowest rung of the patriarchal ladder – the daughter-in-law. She fails to realize that genuine happiness comes from control over one’s own life, not control over another’s.
That said, there are mothers-in-law who understand where the problem truly lies – with the patriarchal set up (and not the “bad” daughter-in-law). Even if they did not live a life of fairness, the better adjusted women (those who’ve developed a healthier response to a difficult life) may obtain happiness by breaking the cycle and treating the daughter-in-law with fairness. They may themselves have more freedom in their later years – having developed an awareness of their rights and an assertiveness that comes with age and experience.
The mother-in-law versus daughter-in-law problem is not a women versus women problem – it’s a problem created by patriarchy. The need for male privilege creates the need for female inferiority. When inferiority is made systemic right from birth and reinforced right through old age, it breaks the psyche and can have extremely unhealthy emotional consequences resulting in unhealthy coping behaviors.
Here are 2 posts that may shed further light on this: