Some assertive ways to deal with manipulation.

A Guest Post by BB-Dlite


I am a long-time reader of IHM. I am really grateful that such a site exists – it has really helped make sense of a lot of strange things that go on in the name of Indian culture, stuff that is taboo to actually talk about openly. One thing that I have noticed is the lack of assertiveness in the concerns that come in – DILs who need permission to visit their parents, sons who cannot set budgets for spending on parents, doctor DILs who hand over all their money to their in-laws, NRIs remote-controlled from thousands of miles away and many other such horrible situations.

The obvious response is to Just Stand Up For Yourself. But having been the victim of emotional manipulation I know that this is a lot easier said than done, especially when it is seen as ‘talking back’ and ‘being disrespectful’. A huge help to me in this aspect has been the assertiveness book “When I say no, I feel guilty” by Manuel J. Smith. It is an old book (1975) but it still has very relevant advice for those who fear confrontation but also don’t want to be walked all over.

I really recommend reading this book; it is 324 pages long so this is just a brief summary. There are many practice dialogues on situations like how to say no to a friend who wants to borrow money/your car, how an adult child can establish boundaries with their parents, how to prompt criticism of your work to get a raise and many more. The first few chapters especially are very helpful in identifying the many ways we can be manipulated and the underlying beliefs that make such manipulation possible. ______________________________________________________________________________

Whenever there is conflict between two animals of the same species, at least one will display a fight or flight response. Among humans it is not really acceptable to fight openly anymore – so we silently grit our teeth and make the empty vow of later revenge.  This is passive aggressiveness. It is also unacceptable to drop everything and run, so another response is passive flight, where we try to avoid that person for as long as possible. A third option is counter-manipulation. These responses usually work poorly and don’t get us what we want. Fight and flight bring up feelings of anger and fear, and if we usually lose this causes frustration, eventual sadness and depression (withdrawal), all very toxic emotions that are best avoided.

The best response to a conflict is verbally communicating with one another and working out our problems in an assertive manner. It is best to state an honest, assertive “I want x” which can then lead to a workable compromise.

What is manipulation? When someone tries to control your behavior to meet their own personal wants by blatant or subtle arousal of feelings of guilt, anxiety or ignorance (e.g. “hurt” or “angry” looks, silences, ridicule). Manipulators can be family members, your doctor, your in-laws, your friends, even your bank teller. A common tactic is setting up arbitrary rules – rules and standards of right and wrong, fairness, reason and logic, or invention of external structure or assumption that it already exists. These are not legally binding rules, just rules that suit the manipulator. Why are people manipulative? Because it has worked for them in the past!

Your Assertive Rights: You have the right to judge your own behavior, thoughts, and emotions, and to take the responsibility for their initiation and consequences upon yourself. You have the right to offer no reasons or excuses for justifying your behavior. You have the right to judge if you are responsible for finding solutions to other people’s problems. You have the right to change your mind. You have the right to make mistakes – and be responsible for them. You have the right to say “I don’t know”. You have the right to be independent of the goodwill of others before coping with them. You have the right to be illogical in making decisions. You have the right to say “I don’t understand”. You have the right to say “I don’t care”. You are your own ultimate judge.

Some assertive ways to deal with manipulation are:

  1. [FOGGING]: assertively cope by offering no resistance to critical statements thrown at you. Just look for the truth in the criticism and agree with it.
  1. Agreeing with the truth: “That’s true, I was out late last night”
  2. Agreeing with the odds: “You could be right”
  3. Agreeing in principle: “You’re right. What you say makes sense, so when I feel the need, I’ll get in early enough.”

Other examples: “You could be right. There are a lot of things I could improve”, “You’re right, I could budget my money better”, “That’s probably true”, “You’re probably right”, “That’s true”, “You may be right”, “My taste is clothes isn’t my strong point”, “I can understand why you think that”, “I’m not surprised you feel that way”

  1. [NEGATIVE ASSERTION]: when dealing with valid criticism or actual mistakes, assertively accept those things that are negative about yourself. Otherwise, if non-assertive, you may (through feelings of guilt and anxiety): seek forgiveness for the error and try to make up for it or deny the error through defensiveness or counter-criticism. In both cases you cope poorly and feel worse.

E.g. Criticism → “You’re right. I wasn’t too smart in the way I handled that, was I?”

A bad haircut: “Yeah, this was a dumb thing for me to try. I don’t like it this way myself”.

An ugly outfit: “I was worried about that. These new styles just don’t suit me at all, do they?”

An error: “You’re right. That was a dumb thing for me to do again and cause you all that work”.


  1. [NEGATIVE INQUIRY]: break manipulative cycle by actively prompting further criticism about yourself or by prompting more information about statements of “wrongdoing” in an unemotional, low-key manner. This is best for people you want to remain on good terms with or who you are going to keep interacting with.

“I don’t understand. What is it about “wrongdoing” that is bad/wrong?” or “What is it about my doing x that is wrong/bad?”

Keep repeating this question until critical issue of the conflict in behavior comes to light. This questioning can extinguish repetitive manipulative criticism from these people so it doesn’t drive you up the wall. This can then lead to a real negotiation of likes and dislikes and a workable compromise. Don’t use sarcasm, which is just thinly veiled verbal aggression.

E.g. “This dish doesn’t taste good.” → “What is it about the dish that tastes bad? Not enough salt? Too spicy?” → “Too much salt” → “Anything else besides the salt?” → “No, that’s it.”

Some more: “Is there anything else about me that doesn’t come off right?” “Is there anything else?” “Will you tell me some more about it?” “What am I doing wrong?”

  1. [BROKEN RECORD]: be persistent and using a calm, repetitive voice say what you want over and over again without getting angry, irritated or loud. E.g. “I won’t be coming over this weekend” or “I want my money refunded.” Another option is “I’m sure that ‘other person’s argument’ [FOGGING] but I cannot do that [BROKEN RECORD]” or “I understand/I see your point/ but I’m not interested”. This will not win you any popularity contests, but just repeat as many times as necessary.
  2. [WORKABLE COMPROMISE]: when you feel your self-respect is not in question, offer to wait, flip a coin, offer up another alternative etc. If the end goal involves a matter of self-worth there can be no compromise.
  3. [SELF-DISCLOSURE]: assertively disclosing information about yourself- how you think, feel and react to another person’s comments. This one doesn’t seem like an assertive skill but being open about your thoughts is actually very assertive behavior – I don’t know, I don’t understand, I don’t care, I changed my mind, I made a mistake, likes, dislikes etc.

E.g. Invitation: “No, I just don’t feel like it this weekend. Let’s try it another time?”

E.g. “What will happen if everyone did ‘something speaker doesn’t like’?” → “I don’t know, what will happen?”

When you are being manipulated you will most likely need to use a combination of the above tools. For example:

Friend: “You’re not going to take that Japanese class, are you?”

You: “I haven’t decided yet.” [SELF-DISCLOSURE]

Friend: “You shouldn’t – it’s just a waste of time.”

You: “Yeah, it could be.” [FOGGING]

Friend: “Well, are you going to take it?”

You: “Maybe, I haven’t decided yet.” [BROKEN RECORD]

Friend: “You should take something practical.”

You: “You’re probably right.”[FOGGING]

Friend: “Well, I hope you make a sensible decision.”


Lastly, a non-verbal assertive behavior is making eye contact. Avoiding eye contact is a learned behavior in response to past conflicts where we have not coped well. If we don’t look at the other person, we don’t get so nervous or anxious. But it is difficult to be taken seriously if you cannot even look the other person in the eye. It is hard to tell when someone is looking at us in the eye (unless eye is moving) within a 9-inch radius around the nose (test this with a friend). So stare at one ear/eyebrow/bridge of nose instead!

The End Result: Being assertive helps respond to manipulative attempts to control your behavior. It also enables the learner to look at his own personal qualities, the ones he has doubts about, without feeling insecure, and to say meaningfully “So what? I do not have to be perfect to be effective and happy.” It desensitizes you to criticism so you are not defensive, anxious, nervous or guilt-ridden when someone tells us something we don’t like. It also helps us to distinguish between the truth in a criticism and arbitrary right and wrong, and trains you to feel comfortable about making and admitting to errors.

It helps in relationships where the other person may be passively coping (maybe due to your defensiveness or flight when criticized) and cannot assertively complain or state what changes are wanted. Without an outlet for resolving differences, any relationship is destined for failure.

It can prompt us to examine our own behavior for manipulation – this sort of behavior is picked up from those around us like fleas.

What if the other person doesn’t give in or is also assertive in return? If you keep your self-respect by exercising your assertive rights, you will feel good even if you do not achieve your goal.

Being assertive sends a clear and unmistakable message “Hey. I’m not manipulatable. I don’t fit into your game plan. You don’t like that? Okay. Find someone you’re more comfortable with.” ______________________________________________________________________________



22 thoughts on “Some assertive ways to deal with manipulation.

  1. I have that book I read it and after some time forgot about it! In Indian circumstances it doesn’t work as much ! Passive aggressiveness is in DNA culture,work and business relationship ! Nobody says an outright ‘no’ in close or relatively close relationship or even business relationship ! People just keep other people hanging here !
    The good thing that book did was that there was something called assertiveness, ,..I need not fight all the time and yes ‘broken record’ tip which I use sometimes


    • Ha! Yes, it’s not easy to be assertive in Indian culture…manipulative behavior is the norm. And some people have decades of experience. I find broken record and fogging the most useful, and even if I don’t get my way I still feel better for not bottling it all up.


  2. Good advice. Also, key to being assertive is never to JADE (Justify, Argue, Defend, Explain). Simply use matter of fact statements. Or respond to a question with a question.

    “Sorry, that doesn’t work for me.”
    “I won’t be able to join you, but you have a nice trip”.
    “I’m sure you didn’t mean for that question to be rude/intrusive/inappropriate, but that’s how it sounded.”
    “Did you just suggest that I was fat/lazy/stupid?”
    “I don’t really know how to answer that.”
    “Wow, I prefer not to answer personal questions.”

    and my favourite:
    “Why do you ask?”

    I used to tape some answers on a piece of paper near the phone ‘cos I used to be tongue-tied at some folks’ rudeness and audacity and didn’t know how to respond. Rehearse a lot and keep the notes handy so that you have a response. Practise makes perfect.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks. Yes, practice does make perfect. When I first started being assertive, people looked at me like I had sprouted a third eyeball. I like your stock phrases! I like to use “I will think about it”, “No, I’m just not into x”, “Sorry that’s personal” and “Why do you need to know?”.


  3. I like this post a lot and while I agree wholeheartedly with the theory, I have a question about practicing this. Is it possible to follow these measures without appearing passive aggressive or sarcastic? Anyone have any real life incidents they’d like to share?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes would like to know too. Especially in work contexts. Sometimes, most of these answers are what go on in my mind, but I don’t say them out loud because for one I am in disbelief at the other person’s behavior and I am afraid anything I would say in response will be aggressive.


      • That’s what ! With these statements its very easy to come across as a selfish,arrogant and rigid !
        Sometimes, even I am unsure about correct response and the response I seek when I communicate with people !
        We indians are emotional ,hyper and easily excitable so I don’t know ! I want friends, don’t want to raise unnecessary conflicts and I want a workable likeable relationships in general ,that’s why though I am born outspoken I am learning to tone it down ! Its difficult in India where its common that people say one thing,think another and do something totally different !!


        • Cosettez, I understand that some of these statements will bring disapproval. Being assertive goes directly against the ideal of a submissive, self-sacrificing bharatiya nari. But, for example, when something as natural as a DIL wanting to spend time with her parents is seen as being ‘selfish’, I think there is no other option than to be seen as ‘selfish’. I don’t like to raise unnecessary conflicts either (fogging is helpful here) but some things are worth standing up for.


    • YES. I tried this with my parents when I wanted out of my first marriage. Our conversations typically went like this:

      Me: I don’t think this marriage is working and I want out.
      Parents: Do you realize what you’re doing is wrong? Yeh sab hamaare yahan nahin chalta!
      Me: What is so wrong about walking out of a relationship that’s not working?
      Parents: (Rambled on for a while) Society mein hamaari naak kat jayegi
      Me: I understand that and I’m sorry for the trouble I’m causing you. But my marriage doesn’t work and there’s no point staying in it. Apart from society is there anything else that bothers you?
      Parents: We think you may be rushing to a conclusion. You should think about it for a while.
      Me: You’re right. I should spend some time away from him and think about it before I decide.

      My parents would be happy for a week, and then bring it up again and the exact same conversation followed. After hearing “this marriage doesn’t work” twenty thousand times they finally gave up.

      Broken record works. Takes a LONG time but it’s very effective.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks. I think it comes down to tone of voice, and your true feelings when manipulated. If you feel angry or defensive, then that is going to come across in your tone as aggression or sarcasm (e.g. Yes, you are SO right). It works best if you cultivate detachment from other people’s opinions and be calmly assertive, which of course is a lot easier said than done.

      In any case, when someone is trying to control your behavior anything other than obedience on your part is not going to be received well. So I think you might as well just say what’s on your mind. You only need to be considerate of someone else’s feelings to the extent that they are considerate of yours.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Good guidance to be assertive in a positive way. The key is to remember this and not get carried away by emotions when the situation arises.

    The challenge I have found is when someone manipulates me in the middle of a sad tale.
    E.g – they are listing all their problems and how someone hurt them and (could be all genuine or partially true or maybe it’s just their own imagined hurt) somewhere in that conversation it becomes “we” , where I become the co-victim and now the person suggests an action that “we” take against another person. Without realizing ,in my righteous indignation , I have been manipulated. It’s too late to do “fogging” etc.

    I’m careful now but being manipulated by a ‘victim’ is the toughest and needs special course in assertiveness .


    • Thanks. It’s actually never too late to be assertive! When someone tries to say “we” should do this/that etc. reply “I’m sorry but I don’t want to take part”, “No, I don’t feel that’s the right thing to do”, “I understand but I’m not comfortable doing that”, and persistently repeat as many times as necessary. It may seem harsh against a ‘victim’ but the alternative is you becoming a victim as well. You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink – be the horse.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Interesting post – makes you think. Would love to see more such guest posts, more voices here.

    Broken record definitely works. I also agree with remaining unemotional and maintaining eye contact.


  6. Pingback: “Practically, what can an introvert DIL do to communicate that she means no disrespect by wanting her own time?” | The Life and Times of an Indian Homemaker

  7. Excellent post, very helpful. Such topics should be made a part of children’s school curriculum and taught from a young age….so that they don’t spend half their lives, like me, in understanding and learning to mange manipulation.


  8. I figured that as long as I am not afraid of not having them in my life, I can say NO! directly or something to the effect of “I think its my business, I would prefer you not interfere.” It makes enemies but it puts out trouble once and for all.


  9. Pingback: “Reading all the comments jerked me up. Really. It was like a bang! And the mind fog moved slightly…” | The Life and Times of an Indian Homemaker

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s